Despite going 2-0 up in the first half, Peterhead had to settle for a 2-2 draw with Brechin at Glebe Park on Tuesday.
An injury-time penalty from Bobby Barr secured a point for Brechin as Peterhead manager Jim McInally lambasted the decision to award the spot kick by referee Stephen Finnie.
“We’ve been cheated at the end of the day. Their first goal the ball went a foot out of play in the build up and we should have had a throw-in,” he said.
“The penalty was the first time I’ve seen one given where the opposition didn’t claim for it, and even they didn’t know what it was for.
“Football can be cruel, you try and take your blows on the chin but when the referee is inflicting those blows on you there isn’t a lot you can do about it.
“Only the referee can say why he wanted to give a penalty but it was nothing short of a disgraceful decision.”
Peterhead unquestionably had the better of the game in the first half, Gary McDonald taking the first chance of the match when his right footed effort from the edge of the box went narrowly wide of the far post.
Brechin had chance through Paul McLean to break the deadlock before Gary McDonald got on the end of a Steven Noble corner after 17 minutes before clanging his header across the face of goal and out.
Less than ten minutes later though the same ball came in and the same man met it at the near post as McDonald scored his fifth goal for the club since joining earlier this year to give Peterhead the lead.
Just before the half-hour mark Peterhead doubled their lead when Brechin failed to properly clear a Cammy Kerr cross and Steven Noble came rushing to the edge of the box to strike the ball first time with venom.
The shot looked destined for the bottom right corner which Brechin keeper Graeme Smith would likely have saved but a deflection off defender Gerry McLaughlan took the ball into the other corner of the net.
With three minutes of time left before the interval Brechin found a route back into the game when Colin Hamilton connected with a Bobby Barr cross in space to volley home from inside the box.
The second half was a much closer affair but it was in the 89th minute as Brechin pushed for a equaliser that Cammy Kerr cleared the ball off the line only as far as Darren McCormack whose shot went over the crossbar.
However, almost inexplicably, the referee awarded a penalty for a push on McCormack after he had hit the ball.
Bobby Barr stepped up to rifle the spot kick home off the underside of the bar.
There was enough time left for both teams to get the ball up into each others halves but a last gasp winner never came.